Is Etsy Worth It for Your Business?
If you’ve ever thought about selling your handmade, vintage, or custom products online, chances are you’ve considered Etsy. With millions of buyers and a reputation for supporting creative entrepreneurs, Etsy seems like a no-brainer. But is it the right move for your business?
Let’s break down the pros and cons so you can decide if Etsy is truly worth it for you.
⸻
✅ The Pros of Selling on Etsy
1. Built-In Customer Base
One of Etsy’s biggest advantages is the sheer volume of shoppers. With over 90 million active buyers, you’re tapping into a marketplace where people are already looking for unique, handmade, or personalized items.
2. Easy to Set Up
Starting a shop on Etsy is straightforward. You don’t need to design a website or worry about backend logistics. Just upload your product photos, add descriptions, set your price—and you’re live.
3. Ideal for Niche Products
Etsy shines when it comes to niche items: embroidered apparel, vintage finds, home décor, personalized gifts, and more. If your product fits the Etsy aesthetic, you’ll likely find an audience that appreciates your work.
4. Trust Factor
Many shoppers feel more confident buying from a known platform than from an independent website. Etsy’s built-in credibility can help you make sales faster when you’re just starting out.
⸻
❌ The Cons of Selling on Etsy
1. Fees Add Up Quickly
Etsy charges several fees per sale:
• $0.20 per listing (renewed every 4 months)
• 6.5% transaction fee
• 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee
• 12–15% offsite ads fee (if Etsy promotes your listing and it sells)
While individual fees might seem small, they can take a significant chunk out of your profit margins.
2. It’s Crowded
There are millions of sellers on Etsy, which means standing out can be a challenge. You’ll need great photos, strong SEO, and regular updates to stay competitive.
3. Limited Branding Control
While you can add your logo and banner, Etsy controls the overall look and feel of your storefront. If building a strong, recognizable brand is your top priority, Etsy might feel restrictive.
4. You’re at Etsy’s Mercy
Etsy owns the platform—and your shop exists at their discretion. Changes to policies, algorithm shifts, or account holds can impact your business overnight. You’re essentially renting a space, not owning it.
⸻
So… Is Etsy Worth It?
Etsy is worth it if:
• You’re just getting started and need exposure.
• You sell handmade, custom, or niche items.
• You’re okay with paying fees in exchange for traffic and convenience.
Etsy might not be worth it if:
• You want full control over your brand and customer experience.
• You sell higher-ticket items where fees eat too much margin.
• You’re ready to scale and want to invest in your own online store.
⸻
The Bottom Line
Think of Etsy as a launchpad, not a long-term solution. It’s a great place to test your products, build an audience, and learn what sells. But if you’re serious about growing your brand, consider also building your own website down the road. That way, you’re not relying solely on a third-party platform.
Want to grow your handmade brand off Etsy, too?
Start by creating a branded experience on your own site while still leveraging Etsy’s traffic—and enjoy the best of both worlds.
https://mckenziesinfinityllc.etsy.com